Since my son and his partner worked quite well together, there was no need for me to really do anything but observe and enjoy! I ended up being in full Agile Coach mode, and what I did observe was quite enlightening.
The instructor had laid out a track on the floor of the room using tape and, since today's session was focused on using the Mindstorm's ultrasonic sensors, some Lego brick walls. The goal was to program the robot to navigate the track, avoiding the walls.
What I thought was really cool was how the kids didn't try to program the entire track at once. They would try to do one thing, e.g. detect the first wall and stop, and then test that out on the track. If it failed, laughter ensued as a wall was bulldozed and the pair would try again using what they learned from the "failure". Once they got that one step working, they moved to the next. Rinse & repeat.
There were some key things I observed:
- NO FEAR OF FAILURE! Was that loud enough? Could you hear me at the back? These kids didn't have to get everything perfect from the start. They experimented, learning more each time and repeating until they got that step right.
- They worked incrementally and iteratively. Each step took one or more experiments, an iteration, and they built the whole program step by step, i.e. incrementally.
- They worked in pairs. I didn't get to spend much time observing the other teams, but my son and his partner were pair programming in every sense I know of. I was a proud Agile Dad! :)
- They delivered. By the end of the 1 hour session, my son & his partner had programmed their robot to complete the course.
So, what is there to learn here?
First and foremost, get over the notion that something has to be perfect right from the start. Experiment, fail, learn, succeed. For example, they had two possible ways of turning the robot and tried both to see which one worked better rather than debate which was the "better" way.
Second, avoid working alone. That's not always possible, but when you can work with someone else, do it! I learned about Pair Programming 10 years ago because I was actually doing it at the time. I still harp on teams to do it, and there is still push-back. Don't give me the introvert excuse, because introversion doesn't mean that you can't collaborate. In any sort of experimental or creative endeavour, multiple minds are greater than one. I saw that this morning with my son and his partner, and I see it all the time in software development when people actually take the time to pair.
Third, you have to actually deliver something. Kids in a Robotics Club is fun, but we're in the business of building software products. If you don't deliver, you go out of business. My son & his partner were able to get the job done despite the experimentation. Actually, I'd argue that they got the job done because of the experimentation, since they incorporated what they learned from their experiments back into their next iteration of work. So, this makes me wonder when many of us become afraid to fail. I would imagine that it's a slow, incremental process, i.e. there is no single event or situation that you could point to. The best people I know and have worked with experiment constantly. Why do so many of us fall into the "Plan the work and work the plan" trap? Is this a personality issue? Are some people preconditioned to experiment, while others are preconditioned to avoid experimentation?
I would also imagine that corporate culture factors into the equation. Would a public sector or very large private sector organization foster creativity through experimentation? Would a company that has downsized repeatedly since the dot-com boom reward people who fail in the small and learn? Based on what I saw today, the corporate world could learn a lot from kids. Experiment without fear, learn, improve, deliver. Simple as that.
Oh, and when my son & his partner finished programming the robot to navigate the initial course laid out, the instructor added a 45 degree turn. The two boys made the fatal mistake of any programming activity... they said, "That's EASY!!" They never did get the robot to make the 45 degree turn! :)